DR. EDITH EGER: STOP ASKING “WHY ME?” ASK “WHAT NOW?”

August 31, 2026 · 👁 4

The Ezras Nashim Elul Series — Part 7

There are things we wish we could go back and change.

Words we wish we hadn't said.

Relationships we wish we'd handled differently.

Time we wish we'd used better.

Kabbalas we made last year and somehow forgot by November.

And then there are circumstances we never chose at all.

Dr. Edith Eger knew something profound about the difference.

What Now?

The late Dr. Edith Eger was a Holocaust survivor who endured Auschwitz and later became a psychologist and bestselling author.

She spent decades teaching about choice—not the fantasy that we can control everything that happens to us, but the human ability to choose what we do next.

One of the powerful shifts associated with her work is moving away from:

Why me?

and toward:

What now?

It is an unexpectedly powerful question to carry into Elul.

Why am I still impatient?

Why do I keep doing this?

Why can't I be more like her?

Why didn't I fix this last year?

Why did I react that way again?

Sometimes those questions teach us something.

Sometimes they simply keep us staring backward.

What now?

You lost your patience yesterday.

What now?

You haven't spoken to someone you love in weeks.

What now?

You rushed through davening this morning.

What now?

You said something you wish you hadn't.

What now?

You made a kabbala and broke it.

What now?

Today Is Still Available

Yesterday matters.

We don't erase responsibility by moving forward.

Teshuva itself requires us to look honestly at what happened.

But looking backward isn't the same as living backward.

Today is still available.

There is still a phone call you can make.

An apology you can offer.

A word you can choose not to say.

A bracha you can notice.

A person you can forgive.

A piece of tefilla you can slow down for.

A different reaction you can choose.

There is something especially fitting about ending our Elul series here.

Charlene Aminoff asked us to stretch without stressing.

Yaffa Palti reminded us not to demand perfection overnight.

Sivan Rahav-Meir turned our gaze inward and upward.

Rebbetzin Esti Hamilton made room for acceptance alongside accountability.

Rabbanit Yemima Mizrachi asked us to guard our gates without abandoning joy.

Rebbetzin Tziporah Heller-Gottlieb reminded us that we aren't stuck.

And Dr. Edith Eger leaves us facing forward.

What now?

Rosh Hashanah will arrive whether or not we have transformed ourselves completely.

Maybe the question isn't whether we finished.

Maybe it's whether we began.

One phone put down.

One word swallowed.

One bracha noticed.

One person called.

One reaction changed.

One small decision made again tomorrow.

Yesterday matters.

Tomorrow isn't here yet.

But today?

Today is still available.

So, what now?

Editor's Note

This article is based on publicly available books, talks, interviews, and other published content from Dr. Edith Eger. Ezras Nashim did not interview Dr. Edith Eger for this story.